Alternatives
Advance decision vs health and welfare LPA
Updated 15 November 2026 · Official fees and timescales checked against GOV.UK on 12 November 2026 · England and Wales
In short
An advance decision (living will) is your own refusal of specific treatment, written down for a time when you cannot decide. A health and welfare LPA appoints attorneys to make care and treatment decisions for you. You can have both, but an LPA made after an advance decision can make it invalid for the same treatment.
Both documents are made under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, both only matter once you can no longer decide for yourself, and neither needs a solicitor. They work in different ways, and the Act has a specific rule about what happens when you have both.
What an advance decision does
An advance decision records treatment you refuse, and the circumstances in which you refuse it. If it is valid and applies to the situation, the people treating you must follow it, as if you had refused at the time. It can only refuse treatment. It cannot ask for a treatment, and it does not appoint anyone.
If it refuses treatment needed to keep you alive, the Act adds four requirements: it must be in writing, it must state that it applies even if your life is at risk, you must sign it in the presence of a witness, and the witness must sign in your presence.
What a health and welfare LPA does
A health and welfare lasting power of attorney appoints one or more people you trust to make decisions about your care, where you live and your medical treatment when you cannot. It must be registered with the Office of the Public Guardian, which charges £92 and takes 8 to 16 weeks, and it can only be used once you lack capacity.
On the form (LP1H) you choose, in section 5, whether your attorneys can give or refuse consent to life-sustaining treatment (Option A) or cannot (Option B, which leaves those decisions to your doctors).
Why the order you make them in matters
Section 25(2)(b) of the Act says an advance decision is not valid if, under a lasting power of attorney created after the advance decision, you gave an attorney authority to give or refuse consent to the treatment the advance decision covers. Section 11(7)(b) says an attorney's authority is subject to a valid advance decision.
- LPA first, advance decision afterwards: the advance decision applies and your attorneys must respect it.
- Advance decision first, then an LPA giving authority over the same treatment: the advance decision stops being valid for that treatment.
- Advance decision first, then an LPA that does not cover that treatment: the advance decision is unaffected.
If you want both, think about the order before you sign either. This is a summary of what the Act says, not advice about your own situation. A solicitor can advise you if your wishes are detailed or your family may disagree.
What an advance statement adds
An advance statement is a written record of your wishes, feelings, beliefs and values about your care. It is not legally binding. But anyone working out what is in your best interests must consider a relevant written statement you made when you had capacity, so it is worth writing whether or not you make an advance decision.
Do you have to pay for an advance decision?
No. The charity Compassion in Dying offers a free form and an online service, and Alzheimer's Society publishes a free template. There is no registration and no government fee. LPASafe sells a version generated from your own words and laid out for signing, for people who want that done for them.
At a glance
| Advance decision | Health and welfare LPA | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Your own refusal of specific treatment | An appointment of people to decide for you |
| Covers | Only the treatment and circumstances you write down | Care, daily life and treatment generally |
| Can ask for treatment | No, it can only refuse | Attorneys can consent or refuse within the law |
| Registration | None | Office of the Public Guardian |
| Government fee | None | £92 |
| Signing | Signed and witnessed if it covers life-sustaining treatment | Donor, certificate provider, attorneys and witnesses |
| If both exist | Not valid for treatment covered by a later LPA | Attorneys' authority is subject to a valid advance decision |
Frequently asked questions
Can I have both an advance decision and a health and welfare LPA?
Yes. Many people do. Check the order: an LPA made after an advance decision makes the advance decision invalid for any treatment the LPA gives your attorneys authority over.
Is a living will legally binding in England and Wales?
An advance decision to refuse treatment is binding if it is valid and applicable to the treatment and circumstances. A refusal of life-sustaining treatment must also be written, signed, witnessed and state that it applies even if your life is at risk.
Does my GP have to sign an advance decision?
No. The law does not require a doctor's signature. Give your GP surgery a copy so that it is on your records, because nobody is told about it automatically.
Which is better, an advance decision or an LPA?
Neither is better; they do different things. An advance decision is precise but narrow. An LPA is broad and relies on the people you appoint. Which suits you depends on your own wishes and who you trust.
Does an advance decision need to be registered?
No. There is no register for advance decisions and no fee. A lasting power of attorney must be registered with the Office of the Public Guardian before it can be used.
Related resources
Which lasting power of attorney do I need?
Property and financial affairs or health and welfare? A clear comparison of the two types of LPA so you can decide which one, or both, you need.
What is a lasting power of attorney?
A plain-English guide to lasting power of attorney in England and Wales: the two types, how an LPA works, who is involved and how to set one up.
Ordinary power of attorney vs lasting power of attorney
An ordinary power of attorney ends when you lose mental capacity. A lasting power of attorney is built to continue. The difference, and which you need.
What is the difference between a will and an LPA?
A will and a lasting power of attorney do completely different jobs. The difference between a will and an LPA, and why many people need both.
Health & Welfare LPA
What a health and welfare LPA (LP1H) covers for care and medical decisions, and when it can be used.
Advance decision (living will)
Refuse specific treatment in advance, in your own words, set out for signing and witnessing. Free forms also exist.
LPASafe covers England and Wales only. Scotland and Northern Ireland use different systems: see Scotland and Northern Ireland. We are not a law firm and do not give legal advice. The LP1F and LP1H forms are available free on gov.uk.
Ready when you are
Put your wishes in writing
A health and welfare LPA, an advance decision, or both. Generated from your answers; no person and no solicitor checks the documents.